Sherlock Holmes: Medievalist!?

This is a medieval blog, but occasionally I will indulge myself with a post on another passion of mine, Sherlock Holmes. Serendipitously, today’s post references both Holmes and the Middle ages. Sherlockiana is the study of all things Holmes, with the conceit that Holmes was a historical figure. Many learned tomes have dealt seriously, in a scholarly fashion, with questions surrounding the world’s first consulting detective and his partner, Dr. John Watson.

A close reading of the canon, those stories written by Watson and edited by his literary agent, Arthur Conan Doyle, show that among his many other interests, Holmes was a scholar of diverse medieval subjects. For instance, in “The Adventure of the Three Students,” published in 1904, but taking place in 1895, we find Holmes on the campus of a great English University researching, what else?, early English (Anglo-Saxon) charters! Controversy rages over which university Holmes visited, but my guess would be Cambridge. (No, really, controversy rages.) Nevertheless, Holmes’ study produced some provocative results, though Watson never tells us what they were. “The Bruce-Partington Plan,” a case from November of 1895, just a few months after “Three Students,” opens at the tail end of Holmes’ two week intensive study of medieval music. Perhaps he was transposing medieval songs for performance on his beloved violin. This curiousity is not limited to 1895. In 1888’s “The Sign of Four,” the second novella in the canon, Holmes mentions his study of miracle plays and medieval pottery.

Holmes’ hobby is not surprising when one considers the intellectual and patriotic climate of the late nineteenth-century. The 1870’s saw the publication of the majority of Stubb’s work on English constitutional history, including a volume on A-S charters. By 1895, it was in its eighth edition. In 1895, England was gearing up for the millenial observance of the death of Alfred the Great, a fine figure with whom to celebrate Empire. This was also the era of Maitland and Harmer, and many other gentleman scholars to whom we owe a debt of gratitude. It is a shame that Holmes’ pen would leave no monograph detailing his findings like the one he wrote explaining the properties of various tobacco ashes. Ah, well, maybe, just maybe, deep in Watson’s tin dispatch box, where he kept the manuscripts of his writings, we might someday find a treatise in Holmes’ hand explaining, in rational, dispassionate prose, the answers to all those questions that vex so much today’s student of the Middle ages.


6 Responses to “Sherlock Holmes: Medievalist!?”

  1. Michelle Says:

    What do you think of Laurie King’s new Holmes novels? I haven’t tried them yet.

  2. heptarchyherald Says:

    I enjoy Holmes pastiches and I even write them. (Ask me about my Sherlock and the Grail story sometime) I have not read any of King’s books, but I hear that they are pretty good. Personally, I guess I am something of a purist. I have difficulty believing that Holmes, a borderline misogynist, would ever marry anyone. It is for this reason that I await the new movie with some trepidation. I just wonder what sort of liberties Guy makes with Holmes…I suppose, though, that we will be forced to hear the origin of the phrase, “no &^%$, Sherlock…”

    • Michelle Says:

      Holmes gets married? Odd; all the reviews of the books have been surprisingly good. Who is Guy? Laurie King is a woman.

      When is this movie supposed to come out?

      • heptarchyherald Says:

        Yes, in the King books, the seventy + year old Holmes marries the twentysomething heroine. Laurie King is a good writer, I just haven’t read her Holmes work. Guy is Guy Ritchie, ex-Mr. Madonna, who directs the new Holmes film, coming out X-mas day, starring Robert Downey, Jr. as Holmes and Jude Law as Watson.

  3. Jonathan Jarrett Says:

    In having a small-scale Holmes obsession you join Roberta Frank and Chris Wickham, so, I’d say that was a good omen 🙂

  4. “There is material here. There is scope.” « @Number 71 Says:

    […] confidence with which he begins to enjoy a mystery he has cracked, or, as the Heptarchy Herald gets excited about, the revelation that our hero is a medievalist; even his bumptious greeting of a threat of arrest […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: